Search databaseBooksAll DatabasesAssemblyBiocollectionsBioProjectBioSampleBioSystemsBooksClinVarConserved DomainsdbGaPdbVarGeneGenomeGEO DataSetsGEO ProfilesGTRHomoloGeneIdentical Protein internet CatalogNucleotideOMIMPMCPopSetProteinProtein ClustersProtein family ModelsPubChem BioAssayPubChem CompoundPubChem SubstancePubMedSNPSRAStructureTaxonomyToolKitToolKitAllToolKitBookgh Bookshelf. A organization of the national Library of Medicine, national Institutes of Health.

You are watching: Health technology assessment in the us is conducted primarily by

Institute of medicine (US) Committee for analyzing Medical innovations in Clinical Use. Assessing clinical Technologies. Washington (DC): national Academies press (US); 1985.


The pressing require for medical modern technology assessment details is obvious throughout the health care industry in the unified States. This chapter provides a profile of medical modern technology assessment in the United states today. An introductory summary is adhered to by explanation of the dimensions of medical an innovation assessment, which suggest the good diversity of current assessment activities as well together unmet assessment needs. Estimates are provided for the family member magnitude that expenditures produced medical modern technology assessment, biomedical research and development, and national health and wellness care. Significant assessment program in the federal government, the drug industry, the medical device industry, and other sectors room described. Finally, conclusions have actually been drawn concerning the adequacy that our existing assessment capabilities and also recommendations have actually been made concerning investment in and conduct the medical an innovation assessment so regarding improve those capabilities.

The thorough profiles of 20 American assessment program in the private and also public sectors, discovered in appendix A, noted much the the basis because that preparing this chapter. Those profiles systematically explain the purpose, innovations assessed, methods, funding, and also other facets of each program.

An Overview

Heightened interest in medical technology assessment has prompted a wide selection of responses in current years as one or another organization do the efforts to accomplish its demands for evaluate information. For instance, since late 1977, the national Institutes of health (NIH) has performed 50 commonly reported consensus advance conferences top top a variety of biomedical problems and also technologies. The American college of Cardiology, the American Hospital Association, and the American clinical Association are among professional and provider associations that have instituted new assessment programs. Implementation that the Medicare prospective payment system, development in multi-institutional health care organizations, competition, and also related factors have prompted health maintenance organizations, hospital corporations, and also other major providers come institute brand-new programs or expand existing persons for assessing their delivery of wellness services and also the cost-effectiveness of fostering and use of clinical technologies. More drug carriers are instituting permanent medicine surveillance and cost evaluation programs. The elevation medical maker evaluator ECRI (formerly the Emergency care Research Institute) is responding come an broadened market because that assessment information with new publications, an implant registry, a widened device-experience report network, and also other services.

Many organizations arrange because that the exchange of assessment information. Blue Cross and also Blue Shield Association and other major insurers increasingly seek aid from clinical associations such together the American university of Physicians, the American university of Radiology, the American university of Surgeons, and the the supervisory board of clinical Specialty cultures in formulating coverage policies. At conference request, the Office of modern technology Assessment (OTA) has actually in recent years produced more than 60 reports and case studies of medical technology that have been commonly circulated and also cited throughout government, industry, and the public. The department of Health and also Human services (DHHS), NIH, and also the Veterans management (VA) are amongst the agencies that have recently describe coordinating committees to enhance the exchange of details about an innovation assessment and also to do recommendations regarding their assessment policies. The Stevenson-Wydler modern technology Innovation plot of 1980 (P.L. 96-480) needs DHHS come report yearly to the room of Commerce about its health an innovation assessment and also transfer tasks (see Office of medical Applications of research , 1984).

Several noteworthy breakthroughs recently have been made about establishment of brand-new assessment entities. The Prospective Payment assessment Commission (ProPAC) was very first appointed in 1983 come make referrals to the DHHS Secretary about adjustments in the Diagnosis-Related groups (DRGs) offered in the Medicare prospective payment system. An academy of medication (IOM) report proposal the facility of a private-public medical an innovation assessment consortium (IOM, 1983). In 1984, Congress set aside funds because that the development of medical an innovation assessment attributes of the National center for health Services Research and earmarked a section of these as corresponding funds because that a nationwide Academy of sciences council on health care technology comparable to that proposed by the IOM (P. L. 98-551).

But the recent flurry of attention to assessment has not been accompanied by a fitting increase in new assessment information. Nevertheless the nationwide investment in health care and the diversity and also scope of evaluate needs, current assessment activities are patchy and poorly funded. Establishments are scrambling for restricted available information and also are relying greatly on professional opinion come fill large gaps in the data. The mass of all sources allocated for an innovation assessment is because that premarketing trial and error of drugs because that safety and also efficacy. Although existing premarketing assessment of drugs and also devices shows up adequate, poor attention is offered to postmarketing study (Joint commission on Prescription medicine Use, 1980; OTA, 1982b). Inadequate attention is paid to assessing medical and also surgical actions for safety and effectiveness (Bunker et al., 1982; Eddy, 1983; OTA, 1982a, 1983b; Relman, 1980). Among all technologies, existing assessment tasks are concentrated on the new and no on the commonly accepted and also possibly outmoded. Assessments the cost-effectiveness and also cost-benefit space few; assessments for ethical, legal, and also other social effects are rare.

Varieties the Medical technology Assessment

Medical modern technology assessment deserve to be described according to countless attributes. As broadened in Table 2-1, this may include the type of technology assessed and its application, the phase of diffusion, the nature or involves of assessment, the techniques of assessment, and assessors. Assorted combinations of these characteristics can be supplied to portray the tasks of specific technology assessment programs and the an excellent diversity among programs. Table 2-2 lists the varieties of modern technologies assessed by some of the programs debated in this chapter. Part programs devote many of their assessment sources to one kind of technology, such as ECRI for medical devices; rather may address a variety of technologies, together does the conference Office of an innovation Assessment. Table 2-3 portrays 150 combinations of three characteristics of assessment: technologies, concerns, and also assessors. Of the 25 selected programs, 16 conduct some assessment of clinical or surgical actions for efficacy or effectiveness. However, as questioned in the remainder that this chapter, the circulation of types of assessment task shown in Table 2-3 is indicative no of the relative comprehensiveness of assessment no one of the loved one investment do in this assessments. Number 2-1 illustrates the family member comprehensiveness the U.S. Modern technology assessment efforts for the miscellaneous classes of technology, and also concerns that assessment.





It is again emphasized that a vast net is cast—broader than most—by use of the term modern technology assessment, as is apparent from Tables 2-1 through 2-3 and Figure 2-1. Primary data gathering as well as various synthesis techniques are included. Evaluate concerns selection from the very circumscribed, together as testimonial of safety and efficacy in assistance of a brand-new drug"s labeling claims, come the many comprehensive, such together a multidisciplinary effort which "systematically examines the effects on culture that may happen when a technology is introduced, extended, or modified with special focus on those consequences that are unintended, indirect, or delayed" (Coates, 1974; see additionally Arnstein, 1977; U.S. Congress, 1966). In enhancement to drugs, medical devices, and medical and also surgical procedures, we incorporate study of support systems and also organizational, delivery, and also administrative systems typically known as health services research. Thus, in the discussion of assorted organizations engaged in an innovation assessment, organ such as the National facility for wellness Services Research and also Health Care an innovation Assessment (NCHSRHCTA, previously known together NCHSR) and university-based wellness services and policy research teams are quote that room primarily associated in health and wellness services research. This more comprehensive view recognizes the interdependence the health care technologies and that making plans to deal with one type of an innovation may have essential implications because that others.

National expenditure for health and wellness Research and Development, Clinical Trials, and an innovation Assessment

The complete dollar level of initiative in technology assessment—including clinical trials, health and wellness services research, and also synthesis activities such together consensus advancement conferences, advanced workshops, and formulation of coverage decisions—is small compared v the national initiative in study and breakthrough of technologies, and also can be shed in the round off error because that national health and wellness expenditures, as is noticeable in the family member magnitudes of the following estimates for 1984.

National health and wellness care$384.3 exchange rate (HCFA, 1984a)
Health R&D11.8 billion (NIH, 1984a)
All health an innovation assessment1.3 billion
Clinical trials1.1 billion
Health solutions researchunder 0.2 billion
Other modern technology assessmentunder 0.05 billion

A quick look in ~ national health and wellness research and development (R&D) expenditure will provide a context for later appreciation that expenditures for medical modern technology assessment. That is noted that health treatment products and services are of varying technical intensity requiring various levels of invest in R&D. Services incorporate ""hotel" and also food services and also microsurgery and neonatal intensive care; assets include tongue depressors and also bandages and also magnetic resonance imagers and genetically engineered agents because that cancer immunotherapy.

Spending for health and wellness R&D in the years due to the fact that 1972 has not kept pace either with the nation"s entire R&D spending or with full national wellness spending. In 1983, once spending for all R&D was virtually $88 exchange rate (National Science structure , 1984), health R&D concerned $10.4 billion, or 11.8 percent, under from 12.4 percent in 1972 (NIH, 1984a).

As a ratio of the $355.4 exchange rate in full 1983 national health expenditures (Gibson et al., 1984), health and wellness R&D amounted to 2.9 percent, under from 3.9 percent in 1972. That is a little higher than the median for every United says industry—estimated at 2.7 percent of the 1984 GNP, increase from 2.3 percent in the 1970s (NSF, 1984)—but low compared with other technologically dependency industries. Those have actually R&D (including commonwealth contributions) together a percentage of sales ranging from 4.2 percent for the chemical industry to 12.2 for computers and office makers to 18.3 percent for aircraft and also missiles (NSF, 1984). Even the defense establishment pegs R&D at 11 percent of estimated fiscal year (FY) 1984 outlays ($231 billion), which encompass pay and also pensions, housing, maintenance, and also other item of small technological contents (U.S. Office that Management and also Budget, 1984). The medicine industry, independently from the rest of health, spends nearly 12 percent that sales top top R&D.

When we come to expenditures for medical modern technology assessment, the estimates indeed come to be rough. In ~ the exterior they amounted to $1.3 billion in 1984. By much the biggest item is $1.1 billion because that clinical trials. Wellness services research study expenditures hardly amount to $200 million. Spending for all the rest of medical an innovation assessment will not reach $50 million because that 1985. Few of the details in this categories are defined below.

The $1.1 billion number for clinical trial expenditures to represent 0.3 percent the 1984 national wellness expenditures. The drug industry is the largest spender for clinical trials—perhaps $750 million in 1984—constituting over one-fifth of the industry"s R&D expenditure (using medicine Manufacturers Association estimates of assignment of pharmaceutical R&D ex penditures; view section below on the drug industry). The next largest contributor is NIH through $235 million in FY 1984 responsibilities (NIH, 1985), or 5 percent that its budget. The third largest contributor may be the medical machine industry, with about $35 million in 1984 (4 percent of the industry"s R&D expenditures). Various other contributors room the VA (approximately $20 million); the Alcohol, medicine Abuse, and Mental Health administration (ADAMHA) ($12 million; OMAR, 1983); and the department of Defense (DOD) (under $10 million; H. Dangerfield, U.S. Military Medical research study and advance Command, an individual communication, 1984). Clearly, the functions of the drug industry and also NIH room dominant; a 5 percent error in the drug market estimate would likely exceed the contribute of any type of of the others except NIH.

Research and also evaluation that organizational and also support systems technologies (e.g., health services shipment modes, payment systems, data bases, and also manpower) are typically grouped under wellness services research. Total annual expenditures for health and wellness services study are probably under $200 million, consisting of some expenditures because that demonstration projects. The mass of wellness services research study support comes from the Health care Financing administration (HCFA), the nationwide Institutes of wellness (NIH), the National facility for health Services Research and Health Care technology Assessment (NCHSRHCTA), and private foundations. 1 other sources include ADAMHA, the Office the the Secretary, DHHS, the wellness Resources and Services management (HRSA), the VA, firm for worldwide Development, and major private service providers such together hospital corporations and also health maintenance institutions (HMOs).

Total estimated expenditures in 1984 because that medical technology assessment tasks other 보다 clinical trials and health services study are fine under $50 million. This has assessment expenditures * because that HCFA ($3 million, FY 1984) and also NCHSRHCTA (under $4 million, including the $0.7 million Office that Health modern technology Assessment budget, FY 1985) and also medical modern technology assessment activities of the Food and also Drug administration (FDA) ($5 million) and the Centers for disease Control (CDC) ($4 million, FY 1982). Additionally included are the whole budgets of together prominent modern technology assessment tasks as the NIH Office of medical Applications of Research, coordinator that the NIH Consensus development Program ($1.8 million, FY 1985); the Prospective Payment evaluate Commission ($3.1 million, FY 1985); the conference Office of an innovation Assessment (OTA) wellness Program ($1.6 million, FY 1985); the bigger medical and industry association program for modern technology assessment such as the American university of medical professionals Clinical Efficacy Assessment task ($0.16 million, 1985), the American clinical Association Diagnostic and Therapeutic modern technology Assessment regimen ($0.38 million, 1985), and the American Hospital combination Hospital Technology collection program ($0.25 million, 1985); non-profit research teams such as the live independence medical an equipment evaluator ECRI ($5 million, 1985) and the Hastings facility Institute that Society, Ethics, and also the Life sciences ($0.25 million, 1985); and the investment in coverage and also reimbursement assessment activities by major third-party payers such together the Blue Cross and also Blue Shield association ($0.35 million, 1984) in support of that plans.

See more: How Many Grams Is 8 Oz To G 8 Ounce To Grams, Convert 8 Ounces To Grams

The complying with four part of this chapter describe an innovation assessment activities in the commonwealth government, the drug industry, the medical machine industry, and also other varieties of establishments in the personal sector. Wherein available, estimates of routine expenditures because that R&D and for clinical trials and also other assessment tasks are provided. Estimates are subject to variations in terminology and also budgeting practices and are necessarily turbulent in details cases. Expenditures for an innovation assessment tasks usually are had in R&D budgets but may not be identifiable as different line items. Amongst organizations that do not normally conduct R&D, such together insurers and also medical associations, an innovation assessment expenditures might be contained in administrative budgets however not determined as such. For particular organizations, the is difficult to make estimates of the expense (or value) of personnel time specialized to technology assessment. Instances are the worth of unpaid attendees in clinical association assessment programs and also the expense of personnel time devoted by NIH and FDA personnel in response to inquiries do by the NCHSRHCTA Office the Health technology Assessment (OHTA) in assessments carried out for HCFA. Available figures for clinical trial expenditure may incorporate all costs of patient care (hospitalization, medical professional services, etc.), or, as is the instance for the VA, they may be confined come the extr costs of conducting a trial over program patient care costs. By reimbursing because that hospital and physician services, private and also public third-party payers provide an indeterminate amount of indirect support for some clinical trials, series, case studies, and also other observations.