I to be wondering how you every go about judging a work of literary works as you're analysis it and/or once you've finished. I don't mean evaluating it with a details lens for definition but just why precisely do you enjoy the publications you do, and how do you know if it was good?


Before answering her question, a few things pertained to mind:

It's an exciting question to ask in a sub like this, namely because this is r/askliterarystudies as opposed to something prefer r/literature. Yet what is the difference between the two?

One method of thinking around the difference can be that literary studies difficulties us to no think in terms of enjoyment, but in regards to understanding. This is no to speak that us don't gain literature, yet that we seek a systematic or - at least - somewhat substantial study of literary styles, aesthetics, approaches, and also periods. Enjoyment doesn't really go into the mix, unless you room doing a "reader response" approach.

You are watching: How should literature be judged?

Many desire literary studies to it is in akin to a science, which ns am resistant come myself. The isn't scientific, but it does share a particular methodology that evidence-based evaluation and argumentation. If literary studies is to be different than just reading literature, it might need come use particular lenses.

how perform you understand if it was good?

From a critical/academic perspective, you can argue, the is impossible to prove that a book is "good". The question implies that the book is or is not good objectively speaking and also that a reader can either notice that quality or miss it. I recognize this isn't what you were implying, yet I think the does go to the core of why literary movie critics are resistant to the "good book" angle: we recognize we have varied reactions and can't really variable those right into our analysis.

Okay. Enough of that.

Personally, i look because that innovative style: literary works that is ready to take threats in its type and play around with share expectations. I additionally like novels the are an ext psychological in your approach and keep points understated fairly than laying everything on thick. I find that I gain impatient with literary works that is heavy-handed or moralistic. Mine favourite literary moment are when a touch of beauty (say, one epiphanic moment) functions its means to the surface of the text through a special mist of man or chaos (if you want to questioning me what qualifies as beautiful, however, that's for another day).

See more: Cuantas Onzas Hay En Un Litro, Conversión De Litro A Onza (Us)

From a personal standpoint. I discover literature great when it renders me feel something strongly or teaches me something i didn't know. Indigenous a crucial standpoint, I uncover literature good when the stakes out a purposeful position in relationship to its contemporary field of production and is able come follow v on that project effectively or in a distinct fashion. A an excellent book makes me desire to write about it.